The Rantings Of A Christian Conservative Gamer

The Right Spin

Credibility Down The Toilet
Newsweek falsely reported that a copy of the Koran was flushed down the toilet by American soldiers during the interrogation of captured Muslim terrorists. This resulted in a riot in Afghanistan that lead to the death of 15 people. Newsweek recently published a retraction stating that this part of their story was false. They had no evidence that this event ever occurred. They close with "Top administration officials have promised to continue looking into the charges, and so will we. But we regret that we got any part of our story wrong, and extend our sympathies to victims of the violence and to the U.S. soldiers caught in its midst." They extend sympathies? That's it? Okay, let's see how sympathetic they really are. What monies do they intend to offer up to these victims? What do they intend to do to offer penance? A big bag 'o nothin'. You know it. I know it. But all is fair in love and bashing war, right?

Michelle Malkin has more.

Marc Landers also asks the poinent question "What does the media do when Muslims use the Bible for toilet paper?"

And, as always, thanks to Dean for giving me something to steal.

Update:


Dadahead makes a good point: Is the Right acting the hypocrite by blaming Newsweek more so than those who actually committed the crime? I'd have to say that the perception could be just that but I also think it's also the venting of frustration. The left-news media has been so virulently anti-Bush that the fact a fabricated piece of evidence (or, to give the left and Mr. Dadahead the benefit of the doubt, unverified evidence) was published, and that this evidence lit a powder keg leading to 15 deaths seems to give firm proof of what many in on the Right has felt all along - the media has swung so far to the left that it has now become dangerous. And that is doesn't care. So, I think this knee-jerk reaction will pass and people will out all blame where it belongs.

A commenter on Dada's site proves, however, that the left itself is more than capable of being a hypocrite too with:


"I'm going out on a limb here, but could the issue at hand have anything at all to do with Afghani frustration at having spent spent the last general under nearly constant warfare and/or foreign occupation and resentment over the continued American military and administrative presence in their country?"


So, it's not Newsweeks' fault, it's not the people who killed others' fault, it's America's fault? The Liberal Avenger, did you even read Dada's post?
Posted by Kevin D. on Monday May 16, 2005 at 4:56am
Dadahead (mail) (www):
Thank you for at least considering my point; it is more than most will do.

Apparently they would, but I use too many f-words.
5.16.2005 7:04am
Kevin D. (mail) (www):
It's easy to nitpick. But it's my pleasure to give your views the fairness they deserve.
5.16.2005 9:36am
RightReader (mail):
Is your complaint that an error was made, or is it that an error was made by Newsweek, a liberal media outlet? It seems that your complaint is based on the fact that Newsweek is considered to be liberal. Do you complain when Fox News makes an error or presents as news items which are clearly editorial in nature? Do you take Rush Limbaugh to task when he makes unsubstantiated statements on his radio program? Perhaps you do; I am a fairly new reader of your blog, so I'll be watching to see. However, I believe that your concerns are based upon the fact that Newsweek is considered to be liberal because you keep using the word liberal in your post. Conservatives such as you are always complaining about the liberal media, but you fail to take into account that there are numerous conservative media outlets as well, especially in the area of talk radio, and that conservative media are equally capable of making unsubstantiated claims or presenting as fact items which are basically opinions.
5.16.2005 11:32am
Kevin D. (mail) (www):
You can be liberal. You can be conservative. I don't care. But during a time of war, if your particular political leanings make the job for the soldiers in the field harder - I'm going to have a problem with you. And of you fabricate a story that leads to the death of 15 people and makes the soldiers' job harder I'm really going to have a problem with you. If it was Fox News that did this I'd be just as pissed. However, Newsweek has a long history of being anti-Bush and has more than once misrepresented the truth. This time it got people killed.

And, so you know, I get most of my news from internet sources. I don't listen to talk radio and rarely watch television news (if I do it is Fox News). And if any of the sources I get my news from screws up, I'll take them to task.

So, RightReader, what do you think about the Newsweek story (and not my reasons for disliking them)?
5.16.2005 8:51pm
AngelLover (mail):
What Newsweek did was reprehensable. That it cleared the Pentagon is astounding. All media, print or otherwise, are morally obligated to have facts confirmed and sources checked thoroughly. That Newsweek did neither is inexcusable.
5.20.2005 10:46pm
Kevin D. (mail) (www):
Also, don't misunderstand me. I don't wholly blame Newsweek for this mess. That a group of people can be whipped into a killing frenzy over the desecration of a book, I don't care if it's a holy text or not, speaks volumes of the people who follow that book. It's a frickin' book, that's it. It wasn't the Koran. There is no the Koran. Just as there is no the Bible.

But, please, if someone can point to a passage in the Koran where it states the penalty for desecrating it is death you'll have gone a long way in clearing this mess up in my mind.
5.21.2005 2:56am
AngelLover (mail):
You make a good point, but it leads to the question: how would some fundamentalist Christians react if the book were a Bible, or Jews if it were a Torah? Religion is, by it's very nature, emotionally charged.
5.22.2005 8:50am
Kevin D. (mail) (www):
I'm sure they'd be upset, and rightfully so, but I sincerely don't think it would cause a riot let alone 15 deaths. No, this baby belongs to Islam.
5.22.2005 11:27pm